The New Zealand Open Source Society

Search

Navigation

  • About NZOSS
  • What is Open Source Software?
  • What are Open Standards?
  • Open Source Resources
  • Company supporters
  • Open Source Projects
  • Event Calendar
  • Events of Note
  • Community
  • Contact Us
  • Job Listings
  • Links
  • Mailing Lists
  • search

NZOSS Company Supporter

  • 3months

    3months is an agile, open source development company specialising in quick to market, bespoke web development using Ruby on Rails. We work with our clients in an environment of trust and transparency where risks are shared, progress is constantly visible and change is embraced. Over the last 10 years our dedicated and personable team have built some of the most exciting and innovative sites in New Zealand.

    Website: 
    http://3months.com
more

New Zealand Open Source Project

  • The Kiaora Project
    Website: 
    http://kiaoracd.org.nz

    The Kiaora Project provides a large number of Open Source programs for Windows that you might wish to have handy when fixing friend's computers and although many of these programs are on TheOpenCD, almost as many are not.

more

Upcoming events

  • No upcoming events available
Add to iCalendar
more

User login

  • Create new account
  • Request new password

News Feed

XML feed
Home

NZOSS Analysis of Ecma OOXML Responses

Submitted by donchristie on March 10, 2008 - 13:50.

Now that the Ballot Resolution Meeting (BRM) in Geneva is over I thought people might be interested in the analysis the NZOSS provided on Ecma's responses to Standards NZ comments. Note that last August Microsoft and Ecma promised they would "fix everything" in time for the BRM. Have a look at the document attached to this article.

As you can see from the attached document, in the lead up to the BRM Ecma offered improvements to only 13 of the 54 SNZ comments. Out of these 13 "improvements" we found only one that really did address the fundamental issue. That's right, Ecma "fixed" 1 comment out of 54.

The BRM voted the vast majority of Ecma's responses through without any discussion so other than one or two isolated cases we can assume that the pre-BRM status quo remains.

That being said, we are still trying to work on the mass of documentation that has come out of the BRM to see what material changes have been made to the proposed ISO standard. Unfortunately there will not be a revised specification to work from, instead we have to apply the results of 1027 (1Kb) responses, plus BRM discussions to the specification. This is a monumental task.

AttachmentSize
application/pdffinal-nzoss-brm-response.pdf716.58 KB
  • Login or register to post comments

All content © the NZ Open Source Society unless otherwise noted. The New Zealand Open Source Society is registered as a charitable entity under the Charities Act 2005. Registration number CC42367

Powered by Drupal. |  Themed by CatalystIT |  Hosted by Egressive |  W3C standards compliant XHTML 1.0 Strict markup and CSS 2.0 styling.